RAGINGDEBATE.COM NETWORK - FACILITATING CITIZEN'S POWERED MEDIA RECOMMENDED AFFILIATE SITE: THEBURNINGPLATFORM.COM
Economy
Energy
Health
World News
Politics

4 Comments

Vote FOR or AGAINST comments below.
RagingDebate.com - therealevil
therealevil
  • Vote
  • 1
  • 0

The opencongress.org page says this bill is dead on arrival.

Of course it's a wicked bad idea, and you should let your reps know what you think about it, but stupid bills like this get tossed out there for consideration all the time.  The person behind this bill knows it's never going to pass, but he needs some red meat for his constituents.

RagingDebate.com - Chilli
Chilli
  • Vote
  • 1
  • 0

This is a bogus, viral email. It contains elements of truth, but is essentially false. (A quick Internet search can reveal the details.) Here is one of the better explanations...

http://www.isra.org/alerts/SB-2099/   --  (copy below)

BTW, as far as I know, bills that are in committee have no expiration and can be resurrected on a dime. That is exactly how the Wall Street Bailout was pushed through so quickly. It was cobbled together from an older bill that had been sitting in committee (possibly staged there for a purpose). Groups like Snopes that discount the threat aspects of these old pieces of stale proposed legislation are being less than honest. While this e-mail is mostly false, the threat of the legislative action isn't.

Eternal vigilance.

----

There really was a Senate Bill 2099, introduced by anti-gunner Sen. Jack Reed (D-RI) but it was in the year 2000.  And it didn't go anywhere.

What this bill would have done would have expanded the National Firearms Act of 1934 to encompass all common firearms to tax and register their sale with the same kind of bureaucracy that goes along with the transfer of machine guns, short-barreled shotguns, and silencers.  The $50 tax and the fingerprinting were indeed part of the attempt, but nothing to do with your Form 1040.

But, to repeat, it's old, it's dead, it's not going anywhere, thanks to the vigilance of gun owners across the nation. 

Update:
Later versions of email about SB-2099 add confusion by describing, in the same post,  HR-45, submitted by Congressman Bobby Rush (IL1-D), the Blair Holt Firearm Licensing & Record of Sale Act of 2009.  This bill is very far reaching, so much so that is has no support from any of Bobby Rush's peers.  Repeat, the bill has no support, no sponsors other than Rush.  Congressman Rush submits a similar bill every session, and it never goes anywhere.  The ISRA and other Second Amendment supporters will remain vigilant,  but the email messages making the rounds make passage of the bill seem eminent.  The bill is stagnant, not moving.

The people who forward these and similar emails are alarmed, naturally, and well intentioned.

  • Vote
  • 1
  • 0

Here is the response I got from the NRA Today. Sorry for the confusion. I trusted the source of that first email. Learned my lesson, and here is what the NRA wrote back:

Here is the response I got from the NRA. I have to compliment them on immediately getting back to me. I'm glad there is such a strong lobbying interest for gun ownership:

Thank you for your inquiry regarding H.R. 45/S.B. 2099.

Over the past few months, NRA-ILA has received hundreds of e-mails warning us about "SB-2099," a bill that would supposedly require you to report all your guns on your income tax return every April 15.

Like many rumors, there's just a grain of truth to this one.  Someone's recycling an old alert, which wasn't even very accurate when it was new.

There actually was a U.S. Senate bill with that number that would have taxed handguns -- nine years ago.  Introduced by anti-gun Sen. Jack Reed (D-R.I.), the bill would have included handguns under the National Firearms Act's tax and registration scheme.  This has nothing to do with anyone's Form 1040, of course.  And, fortunately, S. 2099 disappeared without any action by the Senate, back when Bill Clinton was still in the White House.  We reported about it back then, just as we report about new anti-gun bills every week.  Now, it's time for gun owners to drop this old distraction and focus on the real threats at hand.

To be clear, there is no such bill in the current Congress, and the emails about SB 2099 being sent around are false and unnecessary distractions from real threats.

To read a story by NRA-ILA Executive Director Chris W. Cox on this and other rumors, please click here:  http://www.nraila.org/Issues/Articles/Read.aspx?id=367&issue=047.

As for H.R. 45, in early January of this year, U.S. Representative Bobby Rush (D-Ill.) introduced H.R. 45, also known as "Blair Holt's Firearm Licensing and Record of Sale Act."  The bill is, at its core and as its name implies, a licensing and registration scheme.

The measure calls for all handgun owners to submit to the federal government an application that shall include, among many other things:  a photo; an address; a thumbprint; a completed, written firearm safety test; private mental health records; and a fee.  And those are only some of the requirements to be licensed!

The bill would further require the attorney general to establish a database of every handgun sale, transfer, and owner's address in America.  Moreover, the bill would make it illegal to own or possess a "qualifying firearm" -- defined as "any handgun; or any semiautomatic firearm that can accept any detachable ammunition feeding device..." [emphasis added] without one of the proposed licenses.

Additionally, the bill would make it illegal to transfer ownership of a "qualifying firearm" to anyone who is not a licensed gun dealer or collector (with very few exceptions), and would require "qualifying firearm" owners to report all transfers to the attorney general's database. It would also be illegal for a licensed gun owner to fail to record a gun loss or theft within 72 hours, or fail to report a change of address within 60 days.  Further, if a minor obtains a firearm and injures someone with it, the owner of the firearm may face a multiple-year jail sentence.

H.R. 45 is essentially a reintroduction of H.R. 2666, which Rush introduced in 2007.  H.R. 2666 contained much of the same language as H.R. 45, and was co-sponsored by several well-known anti-gun legislators--including Barack Obama's chief of staff, Rahm Emanuel.

H.R. 45 currently has no co-sponsors. It is in a committee and is not up for a vote.   However, this is an important bill because every element it contains--from regulation of all detachable-magazine semi-autos, to licensing and the elimination of private sales--is part of the agenda of major anti-gun groups.


Thank you again for contacting our office.  Please rest assured that NRA-ILA will continue to monitor these bills closely, and will keep you informed, via our website (www.nraila.org) and magazines, of any developments if they materialize.

Cordially,
Kaelan Jones
NRA-ILA Grassroots Division

Leave a Comment
*NOTE: is our spam filter eating your comments? Become a registered user and login. Click here to learn more.